Mismatched disks in a four-bay NAS, and a rebuild that finished it
The screen said Volume Crashed, and the DiskStation had spent the night rebuilding onto a disk that was already shedding sectors. SHR had spread four mismatched disks across more than one mdadm set, with LVM and btrfs stacked above, so no single disk meant anything on its own. All four were imaged, the layers put back in order, and every share opened.